Book Club 2025: Was this man a genius? by Julie Hecht

I know virtually nothing about Andy Kaufman — I know that Laurie Anderson worked as his assistant for a time, but that’s about it.

I bought it because Julie Hecht has only written four books, and the other three are absolutely amazing, and have reviews like this:

I.e., perfect books.

Kaufman is usually presented as a “comedian and performance artist”, but he seems to me more like somebody really into practical jokes and winding people up. And Hecht isn’t necessarily very interested in veracity, either, so I have absolutely no idea to what degree the entire book is “true”. In any case, it’s presented as being mostly written in the late 70s, as an article for Harper’s Magazine that spun out of control and was never published back then.

But after Kaufman’s resurgent fame (a decade after his death, with a big autobio film — The Man on the Moon), Hecht has polished it up and published it as a book. It describes Hecht trying to interview Kaufman (and succeeding in the end; the last half of the book is 90% transcription of the tapes she made, apparently), but we also get bits like this:

So Kaufman (and his sidekick Bob Zmuda) were sadistic assholes, basically? I mean, a complex and conflicted person (note: code for “sadistic asshole”).

Hecht obviously liked the guy, and Laurie Anderson did, too, so he can’t be all bad, but the description of his routines (like the one where he read The Great Gatsby until the audience started pelting him) really remind me of that 30 Rock bit where they had a documentary on about 70s transgressive humour? Combined with a portion of modern “it’s just a prank, bro”.

Sorry, sorry — I know there’s lots of people who love Kaufman’s stuff. I just don’t respond well to cringe humour.

Anyway. It’s a good book — it’s funny and kinda exciting.

Was this man a genius? (2001) by Julie Hecht (buy used, 3.72 on Goodreads)

Book Club 2025: The Dairy Restaurant by Ben Katchor

I’ve loved Katchor’s comics since the 80s — they’re all perfect and puzzling — they create their own magical world.

This isn’t a comic book, though, but instead a 470 page illustrated book. Let’s have a look.

So we start off with a retelling of the story of the Garden of Eden, and here my problems start already: I just don’t know from this stuff. I mean, I know that it’s supposed to be a garden with an apple tree, and here Katchor has a date tree. But I have no idea whether he’s 1) being satirical, 2) totes blasphemous, 3) presenting an alternative, also valid story or 4) just goofing off. I’m so non-religious that I just can’t tell.

Katchor seems to be writing a polemical text, as far as I can tell from the way many things are phrased, but I just don’t know what he’s arguing against. And the text isn’t funny enough in and of itself — I think this book just isn’t for me. If you were to write a book specifically designed to not have me as the target audience, I think this would be that book.

(Except for the artwork, which is, of course, very nice.)

From what I remember of the Cain and Abel thing, this seems like a fair recap, I guess? Isn’t it?

Were there two sets of tablets in the bible stories? Hmm. Yeah, I think so? Are there differing traditions as to whether they contained different sets of laws?

OK, OK, I’m going to stop — this book isn’t for me, and after reading 50 pages, I skipped the rest.

That is, I skipped ahead a lot, and … this seems to be an overview of dairy restaurants in New York? I’m sure Katchor made his way from the Bible to New York in the 400 pages between somehow…

The Dairy Restaurant (2007) by Ben Katchor (buy new, buy used, 3.60 on Goodreads)

Book Club 2025: Body of Life by Elizabeth Alexander

I’ve noted that young people today (even people that seem pretty cool) apparently have no anxiety around liking stuff that’s popular — even stuff that’s so popular that they may have seen it on regular TV. It sometimes seems to be the opposite way — you see people apologising both for not adoring whatever is popular, or for liking something obscure. These kids are crazy!

Well, I’m old, so I have crippling anxiety around liking something that’s not obscure enough, so when I got this book, and I saw that “Inaugural Poet for Barack Obama” I was horrified! How uncool! That thing was shown on TV! People have heard of her!

But I didn’t notice when I bought it! But I bought a different edition! But officer, I wasn’t even present when I bought this!

The reason I bought this is this:

She wrote the lyrics to and performed on Watermelon City by DJ /rupture. It’s a cool track:

DJ /rupture - Special Gunpowder (2004)

It’s so cool that there isn’t even a separate upload of the track on Youtube — I have to point you to the entire album (529 views).

(The rest of the album is also good, though, so you can just listen to the entire thing, really.)

But no matter how embarassing, I guess I have to read the book sooner or later, so I might as well read it now. *hangs head in shame*

And I’m sorry to have to report that this is a very good collection. Sometimes somebody who’s well-known makes something good! I know! Whodathunk!

I don’t think there’s a weak poem in the book, but some are better than others — I particularly liked this one, but there were a lot of them I really enjoyed.

So what does Goodreads think? Here’s the top review:

But it’s poetry, so there’s just four (4) reviews in total anyway.

Body of Life: Poems (1996) by Elizabeth Alexander (buy new, buy used, 3.70 on Goodreads)

Comics Daze

I finally got a bunch of new comics, both mainstreamey and art stuff! It really seems like US comics is having some kind of meltdown after the Diamond bankruptcy — is it really the case that Drawn & Quarterly only has a single book planned for November? It could just be a programming error on my part, but I really can’t find out who’s even distributing them these days…

Let’s see — what does DCBS say for October?

Yeah, that’s what I thought. Is D&Q via bookstore distributors only now? It seems like this should be a news item or something, but can’t see anything on Comics Beat

Anyway. Finally a comics readin’ day. And let’s go with music from… er… 1981? only.

Japan: Tin Drum (1)

15:49: The Yard by Jack Lloyd

I really like the colour pages here. They have something special going on.

But I mean, the black and white pages are also cool. Kinda 60s undergroundey feeling?

It’s hard to say where the story is going based on this, but it seems like we’re in for a drugged up odyssey.

15:57: Cookies and Herb by Matt MacFarland (Fieldmouse Press)

I got the Fieldmouse books from here.

This is one of those childhood autobio things, and MacFarland manages to make the kid (i.e., himself) pretty unlikable, which is unusual, I guess.

But then again, his dad was an asshole, too, so…

Yukihiro Takahashi: Neuromantic

16:11: Ms. Understood by Juliette Collet (Neoglyphic Media)

I really like the artwork…

Is it done with coloured pencils and crayons? Very attractive.

The stories are mostly about S&M and porn, but take some detours into other subject matter, too.

16:34: Womb Rider by Emil Friis Ernst (Uncivilized Books)

This is like an American (? I don’t know) version of Yuichi Yokoyama.

Very loud. But in a car instead of walking! It’s good stuff — very visceral, but the twist ending is a bit of a letdown.

The Cure: Faith (1)

16:39: Cannon by Lee Lai (Drawn & Quarterly)

This isn’t quite the kind of book I usually enjoy — that is, initially it felt like it’s one of those books that’s really a pitch for an indie movie (perhaps because I didn’t really take to her previous (much-awarded) book).

But then things really changed and it’s something else altogether.

It’s an intricate and compelling book. It’s quite original in many ways, and ends up being gripping and moving. Very surprising.

Simple Minds: Sister Feelings Call

17:41: Unrest by Jurijs Tatarkins (Fieldmouse Press)

This is fun!

I like it.

Simple Minds: Sons and Fascination

17:49: Who Killed Nessie? by Paul Cornell/Rachel Smith (Avery Hill)

This is very high concept — it’s about a convention for supernatural beings, and then there’s been a murder! And a human has to investigate.

So that sounds fun, but who is this for, really? There’s endless sex jokes in here, so it’s not for children… but the tablet-ey art style is totally for children.

And it really gets bogged down in one info dump after another about the mechanics of supernatural beings. It unfortunately has the whiff of “YA adults” — grown ups who think way too much about children’s literature.

It started off well, and then just became crushingly tedious.

18:30: The Museum of the History of the Ideas about the Fall by Goda Trakumaite (Domino Books)

I got this from here.

This is really cool. It’s a comics essay about health care and stuff. I really like the artwork here — it feels solidly 70s Undergrounds — very attractive. And for an essay, the storytelling is very solid.

I particularly liked the framing of witches’ medicine as empirically based while mainstream medicine (well, in those days particularly) was based mostly on superstition.

18:55: Laser Eye Surgery by Walker Tate (Fantagraphics)

I’ve loved all books by Tate that I’ve read. They’re mostly kinda oblique, and many are based on dance. This is very different — it’s a quite straightforward story — a horror story, and it’s really unnerving. Ace!

But of course it’s a Walker Tate book, so you also have wonderful pages like this.

Fantastic book.

Tom Tom Club: Tom Tom Club

19:05: Dark Garbage by Jon-Michael Frank (Floating World Comics)

This is a lot of fun. Vague adventures filled with gags, but also musings on life and stuff.

Heh heh, just when I read “as above so below” here, the Tom Tom Club were singing the same lyrics! It’s a miracle!

I really enjoyed the book. It’s got something going on.

Tuxedomoon: Desire

19:59: Selections from the Richy Vegas Songbook 2 by Richard Alexander

This doesn’t use the circular storytelling thing that Alexander uses in his main series…

… but it’s still fascinating. It’s autobio stuff from a unique viewpoint, and it really grabs your attention. The storytelling is flawless.

Kraftwerk: Computer World

20:12: Doctor of the Shawo by Olga Volozova/Daniel Volozov

I don’t think I’ve seen a comic book done in this fashion before — it’s cut-outs and dioramas with dolls, and then backgrounds are drawings…

It’s interesting — it’s about a mother and a son going to a psychologist (or do they?), and it spins out in an abstract way. I like it.

Talking Heads: The Name Of This Band Is Talking Heads (Disc 1: 1977-1979)

20:23: The Hanging by Aaron Losty (Strangers Publishing)

I think I got this from here?

This is a really attractive book. I mean physically — perfect paper stock, binding, printing… and I love these colours. Somebody should win a design award.

Ooooh — the artwork has a real French pop art thing going on.

It’s pretty good all over — it’s a dystopian story of people trying to survive in the near future.

20:56: Pushing Buttons by Ursula Blix (Black Panel Press)

Speaking of design… this is just uncomfortable. The paper is super shiny, so I have to tip it every which way to see what’s on the page. And that coupled with the tiny lettering and the colour scheme just makes reading this a chore.

Which is a shame, because it’s otherwise a charming book.

21:11: Collected Oil by James Tonra (Desert Island)

Whoa! Cool.

I have absolutely no idea what’s going on in any of these short pieces, but it’s fun to look at.

21:25: The Thing vs. the Marvel Universe by Ryan North and others (Marvel Comics)

Oh, it’s all single panel pages? It’s a long slug fest? Sure, why not.

But it’s so badly done! The pages look awkward and stiff, and they’re apparently not be meant to read next to each other, because they look like double page splash pages more often than not (and they’re not).

The twist ending is fun, though, so Ryan delivers on that point.

21:36: The End

And now I think I’m going to make dinner, so I guess it’s time to call it a day.

Book Club 2025: The Vor Game by Lois McMaster Bujold

I’m at the tail end of a cold here, so it felt like the perfect time to bundle up on the couch with a Bujold book. I’ve read this a couple times before, but the last time is at least 15 years ago, so I remembered virtually nothing about this book.

And it’s just what the doctor ordered. It’s a delight to read — amusing, exciting, well-written. It’s all that good stuff. And now my cold is gone!

One thing I did notice this time around was how utterly dependent on happenstance and coincidence Bujold was in this novel. I mean, the protagonist goes halfway across the galaxy and just happens to meet up with [redacted], like one does. And then happens to meet a spaceship piloted by [redacted]. And so on. It’s so shameless that it almost reminds me of (early) P. G. Wodehouse — sometimes he really couldn’t be bothered to think out anything resembling a plot, so he’d just have everybody stumbling over each other in various cities.

I mean, I’m not complaining — the random coincidences add a certain something to the proceedings.

It’s good fun — I was smiling the entire time I was reading this.

The Vor Game (1990) by Lois McMaster Bujold (buy used, 4.27 on Goodreads)