This is a pre Hayes code movie – I don’t think that costume would have flown afterwards?
This is a very odd movie. I just read the Criterion text on the DVD cover, and apparently this was going to be a George Cukor movie, but then Lubitsch got involved and re-shot a lot of the scenes, and… drama!
But I mean, it’s a fun movie, but it’s weirdly aimless. I feels like watching one of those 70s movies? About hippies wearing fringe coats and talking about freedom and stuff?
So it’s prescient and weird, but isn’t not actually that entertaining?
One Hour With You. George Cukor, Ernst Lubitsch. 1932.
This is another 1.2:1 movie — the early talkies used a portion of the normal 1.37:1 film stock to carry the audio, so the movies became narrower. (The first few sound movies Lubitsch did, and were filmed twice, and released in both 1.37:1 silent versions and 1.2:1 talkie versons.)
So that’s where “simp” comes from!
That’s the simp.
This is fun! Lubitsch’s previous movie was a downer, but this is moving along most amusingly.
Sing it, girl! Sing it!
Jeanette MacDonald is great. But this just isn’t firing on all cylinders. It’s got scenes that should be hilarious, but instead they’re just vaguely amusing. I think it’s mainly a pacing problem? I mean, I know — this is from 1930 — but I’ve seen movies from 1930 that have more snap and zip.